← Back to the blog

Basics

Turntables and records: direct drive or belt, cartridges and what really matters

· 18 min read

In short: With a turntable, the thing people argue about most matters least for the sound: the drive. Belt drive and direct drive both sound excellent if they are well made. Direct drive has more accurate speed and needs no maintenance. Belt drive gives you a lot for little money. What affects the sound most is the cartridge and the shape of its stylus, correct setup, a decent phono preamp and the record itself, meaning how it was recorded and pressed. Add the speakers and the room, as with any source.

In this article:

  1. How a record works
  2. The RIAA curve: why a record needs its own preamp
  3. The turntable part by part
  4. Belt or direct drive
  5. Cartridges: MM, MC and others
  6. Stylus shape: a small detail with a big effect
  7. The tonearm and cartridge must match
  8. The phono preamp
  9. Setup step by step
  10. Where to put the turntable
  11. Records: pressing, cleaning, storage
  12. Digitising records
  13. The most common myths
  14. What to buy
  15. Short glossary

How a record works

A record is sound carved into plastic. The groove runs from the edge to the centre as one long spiral. On one side of an LP it is about 500 m long. Its walls wiggle exactly in step with the sound wave. The stylus slides along the groove, vibrates with the wiggles, and the cartridge turns these vibrations into electricity.

On a stereo record each groove wall carries one channel: the inner wall the left, the outer wall the right. The walls are tilted at 45°, so this is called the 45/45 system. When both channels play the same, the stylus moves sideways. A difference between them moves it up and down. Thanks to this, a stereo record can also be played on an old mono turntable.

TypeSpeedMaterialWhen
shellac record78 rpmshellac, brittleuntil the 1950s
LP (long play), 30 cm33⅓ rpmvinylfrom 1948 (Columbia)
single, 17 cm45 rpmvinylfrom 1949 (RCA)
stereo LP33⅓ rpmvinylfrom 1958
maxi single, 30 cm45 rpmvinylfrom the 1970s, disco and DJs

One quirk of the record matters for everything that follows: the platter always turns at the same speed, but the groove circumference gets smaller towards the centre. At the edge of an LP the groove passes under the stylus at about 0.5 m/s, near the end only at 0.2 m/s. So near the end of the record the same treble is “squeezed” into a stretch two and a half times shorter. That is why the last track on a side is usually the least clean.

The RIAA curve: why a record needs its own preamp

If music were cut into a record as it is, the bass would make huge swings, neighbouring grooves would touch and only a few minutes would fit on a side. The treble, on the other hand, would be so fine that the noise of the material would drown it out. So during production the bass is turned down and the treble turned up, and on playback this is reversed exactly. Since 1954 a single standard curve has been used for this. It was introduced by the American RIAA association and later adopted by an international standard too.

-24-18-12-60+6+12+18+2420 Hz100 Hz1k Hz10k Hz20k HzdB123
The RIAA curve. 1 (red): how music is written to the record, with the bass turned down and the treble turned up. 2 (blue): how the phono preamp corrects it on playback, boosting by about 19 dB at 20 Hz and cutting by about 20 dB at 20 kHz. 3 (gold): the result is flat.

The curve has a nice side effect too: when the preamp turns down the treble, it also turns down the noise and crackle of the record. Without it, records would hiss much more.

This leads to a practical rule: you cannot plug a turntable into a normal input on an amplifier. The signal is weak and the treble is boosted, so it would play quietly, harshly and without bass. There has to be a phono preamp between the turntable and the amplifier. More on that below.

The turntable part by part

  • Platter: turns the record. A heavier platter turns more evenly, because its inertia smooths out small irregularities in the drive.
  • Drive: the motor and the way it turns the platter, meaning belt or direct drive.
  • Tonearm: holds the cartridge and guides it over the record. It must move completely freely, yet have no play.
  • Cartridge: the stylus with its cantilever and a generator that turns the stylus movement into electricity.
  • Plinth and feet: are meant to stop shocks from the floor and sound from the speakers from reaching the stylus.
  • Phono preamp: in the turntable, in the amplifier or as a separate box.

Belt or direct drive

This is the most common dilemma when buying. Both have their advantages and both can be excellent.

BeltDirect drive
How it worksthe motor sits to the side and turns the platter through a rubber beltthe platter sits directly on the motor
Motor vibrationthe belt filters it outtiny with modern coreless motors
Speed accuracydepends on the belt and the motor controlmonitored electronically, often with a quartz oscillator
Start-upa few secondsinstant
Maintenancethe belt stretches and is replaced every few yearsalmost none
Switching 33/45on cheap models by moving the belt by handwith a button
For DJsnot suitableyes
Typical modelsPro-Ject Debut, Rega Planar, Linn LP12Technics SL-1200 and SL-1500C, Audio-Technica AT-LP120X, Denon DP-3000NE

A bit of history

In the 1970s direct drive was new, and the Technics SL-1200 from 1972 became a legend, especially among DJs. But the first direct drives had motors with an iron core that turned slightly jerkily (cogging), and a faint vibration got into the record. So audiophiles leaned towards belt drive, which separated the motor from the platter. This view has survived to this day, even though modern coreless motors and precise speed control solved the problem. Technics restarted production in 2016 after a break.

A third, historical drive is the idler wheel (idler), which presses on the rim of the platter, for example in the Garrard 301 or Thorens TD 124. It has strong torque and stable speed, but passes motor noise on more easily. Today it is mainly for collectors.

Speed variation

When the platter does not turn perfectly evenly, the pitch wavers slightly. Slow wavering is called wow, fast wavering flutter. You are most likely to hear it on long notes from a piano, a flute or a solo voice.

0 %12345
Typical speed variation in percent, from top to bottom: 1 cheap turntable, 2 good belt-drive turntable, 3 direct drive of the Technics SL-1200 class, 4 cassette deck, 5 CD and streaming (no variation). The solid bar is the better, the light bar the worse end of typical figures. The red dashed line is about 0.1 %, around which most people start to hear it on long notes. Manufacturers use different measuring methods, so the numbers are only a rough guide. The vertical lines are 0.05 % apart; the full width of the chart is 0.3 %.

Direct drives are the most accurate, but even a good belt-drive turntable is below the threshold of hearing. Cheap turntables of both types, belt and direct drive, have a stated variation of around 0.1 to 0.25 %. So the quality of the specific model matters more than the type of drive.

What to choose

  • Direct drive if you want accurate speed, instant start and no maintenance, or if you want to mix and scratch.
  • Belt if you want a simple turntable with a good cartridge for little money. Makers such as Rega and Pro-Ject offer a lot for the price.
  • With a used belt-drive turntable, count on a new belt for a few euros. An old stretched belt is the most common cause of a “wobbly” pitch.

Cartridges: MM, MC and others

The cartridge is to a turntable what a speaker is to a system: a transducer that turns movement into electricity. It has the biggest effect on the sound of all the turntable’s parts.

TypeHow it worksOutputStylusFor whom
MM (moving magnet)a tiny magnet sits on the cantilever, the coils are fixed3 to 6 mVyou replace it yourselfmost people
MI (moving iron)similar to MM, a piece of iron vibrates2 to 5 mVusually replaceablelike MM (for example Grado, Nagaoka)
MC (moving coil)tiny coils sit on the cantilever, the magnet is fixed0.2 to 0.5 mV, high-output versions around 2 mVonly the maker or a service can replace itadvanced users
ceramica crystal that produces voltage when benthighheavy tracking forcenobody, it ruins records

MM cartridges are the best place to start. They are cheap, have enough output for any phono input, and when the stylus wears out you just buy a new stylus. A good MM cartridge with a fine stylus plays better than a cheap MC.

MC cartridges have a lighter moving system, so they can track the groove better. But their output is ten times weaker, so they need a very low-noise MC preamp or a step-up transformer. When the stylus wears out, you replace the whole cartridge or send it off to be retipped.

Ceramic cartridges are found in cheap suitcase record players. They press on the record with a force of 5 g or more, and the stylus is coarse. They sound bad and ruin records. If you have rare records, do not play them on such a player.

Stylus shape: a small detail with a big effect

The stylus tip is a tiny diamond. What matters most is how rounded it is where it touches the groove walls. The smaller this rounding, the finer the wiggles the stylus can follow.

ShapeContact radiusProsConsLifespan (approx.)
spherical (conical)15 to 18 µmcheap, easy to set up, forgiving with worn recordsweaker treble, more distortion near the end of the record300 to 500 hours
elliptical5 to 8 µmclearly better treble, a good compromiseneeds more precise setup300 to 500 hours
fine profiles (Shibata, MicroLine, Fine Line and others)2 to 6 µmbest tracking of treble and the end of the record, longer lifespanmore expensive, setup must be preciseup to about 1,000 hours
10 µm123
A 20 kHz wiggle near the end of the record, to scale. At 33⅓ rpm and 60 mm from the centre, one wiggle is only about 10.5 µm long. The circles show the stylus rounding at the same scale: 1 spherical (15 µm) is larger than the whole wiggle and does not fit into its dips, 2 elliptical (5 µm) and 3 fine profile (2.5 µm) follow it much more faithfully. Simplified: a real stylus touches the side walls of the groove.

The stylus wears down. A worn stylus has flat spots with sharp edges on its sides, and these damage records. The sound gets worse slowly, so you often do not notice. It is worth keeping a rough count of playing hours. With normal listening of an hour a day, an elliptical stylus lasts one to two years.

The tonearm and cartridge must match

The springy stylus suspension (cartridge compliance) and the tonearm mass together form a spring with a weight. They have their own resonance, much like a driver in a box. This resonance should sit between 8 and 12 Hz:

  • below 8 Hz it gets excited by warped records and footsteps on the floor, the stylus may skip and the woofer moves for no reason,
  • above 12 Hz it already reaches into the deepest bass of the music.

Resonance = 159 / √(mass × compliance), mass in grams, compliance in µm/mN (manufacturers state it in “cu”, which is the same thing). The mass is the effective mass of the tonearm plus the cartridge with its screws. For example a 12 g tonearm, a 6 g cartridge and 1 g of screws, 19 g in total, with a cartridge of 15 µm/mN compliance: 159 / √(19 × 15) = 159 / 16.9 = 9.4 Hz. Excellent.

Tonearm (effective mass)Suits a cartridge with complianceTypically
light, up to 10 ghigh, above 20 µm/mNsoft MM cartridges
medium, 10 to 20 gmedium, 10 to 20 µm/mNmost MM and many MC, the most common combination
heavy, above 20 glow, below 10 µm/mNstiffer MC cartridges

Careful: Japanese makers often state compliance measured at 100 Hz, which is roughly 1.5 to 2 times lower than the value at 10 Hz needed for this calculation.

The phono preamp

The phono preamp (phono) does two things: it amplifies the weak cartridge signal about a hundred times (MM, around 40 dB) to a thousand times (MC, around 60 dB), and it flattens the RIAA curve back out. It can be:

  • in the turntable, then you connect it to a normal input (it can often be switched off),
  • in the amplifier, an input labelled PHONO,
  • separate, from about 50 € upwards.

What to watch out for:

  • Cartridge type: an MM input is not enough for a normal MC cartridge. It will play quietly and hiss.
  • MM cartridge load: the standard is 47 kΩ, and the total capacitance as specified by the cartridge maker, usually 100 to 200 pF. The capacitance includes the tonearm cable and the input. If the capacitance is too high, a bump appears in the treble with a steep drop above it. You will find an example in the article Audio cables.
  • Grounding: a turntable usually has a separate ground wire. Connect it to the GND terminal on the preamp, or it will hum.
  • Rumble filter (subsonic filter): turns down the deepest frequencies below 20 Hz from warped records. This saves the woofers from pointless movement, especially in a bass reflex.

Setup step by step

Setup is free and has a bigger effect on the sound than a more expensive turntable. You need a spirit level, a digital stylus force scale (around 10 to 20 €) and an alignment protractor, which you can print for free.

  1. Level. Put the spirit level on the platter and adjust the feet.
  2. Balance the tonearm. With no tracking force, move the counterweight until the tonearm floats freely and level.
  3. Tracking force: set it as the cartridge maker says, usually 1.5 to 2.5 g, and check it with the scale. The scale on the counterweight is often inaccurate. Too light a force is worse than slightly too heavy: the stylus bounces in the groove and damages the wall.
  4. Anti-skating: set it to roughly the same value as the tracking force. It compensates for the force that pulls the tonearm towards the centre of the record.
  5. Alignment. Turn and slide the cartridge in the headshell according to the protractor, so that at two points on the record it lines up exactly with the groove. The best-known protractors are Baerwald and Löfgren. This matters with fine styli.
  6. Tonearm height (VTA), if it can be adjusted: the tonearm should be roughly level while playing.
  7. Azimuth: seen from the front, the cartridge must be at a right angle to the record.

After setup, play a test record or a track with loud vocals near the end of a side. If the “s” and “c” sounds clearly crackle or are smeared, check the tracking force and the alignment.

Where to put the turntable

The stylus is a sensitive vibration sensor. It picks up not only the groove but also vibration of the table, footsteps and sound from the speakers. With a loud bass note, feedback can build up: the speaker shakes the table, the stylus picks it up, the amplifier amplifies it, and the bass starts to boom or even howl.

  • Put the turntable on solid, heavy furniture, not on the same shelf as the speakers.
  • With a wooden floor, a wall shelf helps.
  • Do not put a subwoofer right next to the turntable.
  • For damping, a hard mat or damping feet are enough. They do not need to be expensive.

The rest is the same as with any source: the speakers and the room make the biggest difference. See the article The room plays along.

Records: pressing, cleaning, storage

Not all records are equal

How the record was recorded, mastered and pressed affects the sound more than the turntable does. The same recording can sound completely different on different editions. When buying, it is worth checking reviews of the specific edition, for example on Discogs.

  • 180 g weight does not mean better sound. A heavier record warps less and feels luxurious, but the groove is the same. Quality is set by the pressing plant and the master.
  • Digital master: many new records are made from digital files. That is not a flaw, it just is not “pure analog”. More in the article Analog or digital.
  • Typical pressing faults: warping, an off-centre hole (the pitch slowly drifts up and down), noise from impurities in the vinyl, crackle.

Cleaning

  • Before every play, sweep the record with a carbon fibre brush, which picks up dust and reduces static.
  • Wet cleaning now and then, or when buying second-hand: a special solution or distilled water with a little isopropyl alcohol and a drop of non-ionic detergent, a soft brush and thorough drying. Do not use tap water, it leaves limescale.
  • A vacuum record cleaning machine or an ultrasonic cleaner is the most effective and is worth it for a larger collection.
  • Never clean shellac records (78 rpm) with alcohol, shellac dissolves in it.
  • Clean the stylus with a soft brush from back to front, never sideways.

Storage

  • Store records upright, not in a pile, and not squeezed together.
  • Keep them away from heat and sun. A record will warp in a car or next to a radiator.
  • Replace paper inner sleeves with anti-static ones. Paper scratches the record and sheds dust.
  • Hold the record by the edge and the centre, not by the groove.

Digitising records

Rare records are worth recording to a computer. Then you can listen to them without wear, and the original stays safe.

  • A turntable with a USB output, for example the AT-LP120XUSB, or a preamp with a sound card.
  • Recording at 24 bits and 48 to 96 kHz is enough. The free program Audacity handles both recording and crackle removal.
  • Clean the record thoroughly before recording. You will save yourself a lot of work fixing crackle.

Interestingly, a well-made digital copy of a record sounds like the record, with everything that comes with it. This shows that the character of vinyl is in the recording itself, not in whether playback is analog.

The most common myths

  • “Direct drive sounds worse.” That was true of the first motors with an iron core in the 1970s. Today’s direct drives are among the most accurate turntables.
  • “A record has more detail than a CD.” Measurements say the opposite: CD has less noise, less distortion and better channel separation. A record may sound better to some people, for example because it is mastered differently. More in the article Analog or digital.
  • “A 180 g record sounds better.” The groove is the same. The master and the pressing are what count.
  • “Every play destroys the record.” It wears a little, but with a correctly set up cartridge and a clean stylus only very slightly. What mainly ruins records is a worn stylus, a ceramic cartridge and dust.
  • “More expensive turntable = better sound.” Above a certain price, the cartridge and setup are what mostly count. A 300 € turntable with a good cartridge and setup will play better than a badly set up one for 3,000 €. More about what else matters in the article Hi-fi and high-end.

What to buy

Budget (rough guide)ExamplesNote
200 to 400 €Audio-Technica AT-LP120XUSB (direct drive), Pro-Ject Debut Carbon EVO (belt), Rega Planar 1 (belt)a good start, mostly with an MM cartridge, some with a built-in preamp
500 to 1,200 €Technics SL-1500C (direct drive, with preamp), Rega Planar 3 (belt), Pro-Ject X1 and X2 (belt)solid quality for years, a better cartridge is worth it
above 1,200 €Technics SL-1200 and SL-1210GR, Denon DP-3000NE (direct drive), Rega Planar 6 (belt)most of the improvement comes from the cartridge and preamp
second-handolder Technics SL-1200/1210, Dual, Thorens TD 160, Pioneer, Sonycheck the tonearm bearing, speed and belt, and count on a new stylus
do not buysuitcase players with a ceramic cartridgethey ruin records

Where to spend your money, from biggest effect down:

  1. the speakers and their placement in the room,
  2. a cartridge with an elliptical or finer stylus,
  3. correct setup (almost free),
  4. clean records and good editions,
  5. a decent phono preamp,
  6. only then a more expensive turntable.

Short glossary

  • Cartridge: the part with the stylus that turns the stylus movement into an electrical signal.
  • MM, MI, MC: types of cartridge, named after what vibrates inside: a magnet, iron or a coil.
  • Tracking force: the force with which the stylus presses on the record, stated in grams.
  • Anti-skating: a force that balances the pull of the tonearm towards the centre of the record.
  • RIAA: the standard by which bass is turned down and treble turned up during production, and reversed on playback.
  • Phono: a phono preamp or the input for one.
  • Wow and flutter: slow and fast speed variation.
  • Rumble: a low hum from the motor or the platter bearing.
  • Compliance: how easily the stylus suspension bends, stated in µm/mN.
  • Effective tonearm mass: the mass the stylus “feels” when the tonearm moves.
  • VTA and azimuth: the tilt of the cartridge front to back and side to side.

Sources: RIAA standard (1954) and IEC 60098; data from turntable and cartridge makers (Technics, Audio-Technica, Ortofon, Rega, Pro-Ject, Denon); B. Baerwald, Optimum Tracking Angle (1941) and E. Löfgren (1938) on tonearm geometry; RIAA, 2022 year-end report; history of the LP and single formats (Columbia 1948, RCA 1949). The calculations of the RIAA curve, groove speed and tonearm resonance are our own.

Free tools: Room planner · Speaker measurement · Blind ABX test