Room acoustics
Subwoofer: none, one or two?
In short: A subwoofer is not just “more bass”. Set up well, it takes the load off your main speakers, lets you place them where the midrange sounds best, and puts the bass where the room does the least damage. The biggest bass problem at home is not the speaker but the room modes: the level of a single note can vary by as much as 20 dB from one spot in the room to another. One well-placed subwoofer improves that in one seat. Two subwoofers in the right places, according to research at Harman, even out the bass for several seats at once. Without measuring and tuning, though, even an expensive subwoofer often sounds worse than none at all.
In this article:
- What a subwoofer brings
- Below 200 Hz, the room is in charge
- Why two beat one
- Where to put it
- Crossover frequency
- Phase and delay
- Level and measuring with REW
- Sealed box or bass reflex
- Size versus depth
- Stereo or mono bass
- Home theatre: LFE and bass management
- Build your own subwoofer with Loudsmith
- What to choose when
- Key takeaways
- Short glossary
What a subwoofer brings
A subwoofer is a speaker for the lowest notes only, usually from 20 Hz up to 80 or 120 Hz. It has a large driver, its own amplifier and a filter that lets only the bass through. It brings three things, and only the first is the one most people think of.
- Deeper bass. A bookshelf speaker with a 15 cm woofer runs out at around 50 to 60 Hz. The lowest string on a bass guitar is 41 Hz, on a five-string 31 Hz, and pipe organs, film explosions and electronic music go below 20 Hz. A small box simply cannot play these notes, however hard the amplifier drives it.
- Relief for the main speakers. The deepest bass forces the largest cone movement. Filter it out of the main speakers and their woofers move far less, distort less in the midrange too, and the amplifier has more headroom. Small speakers can then play louder.
- Freedom of placement. You put the main speakers where the stereo image works. The bass comes from the subwoofer, which stands where the room spoils it least. Those two places almost never coincide, and that is exactly why a subwoofer is so useful even with large floorstanders.
Why can't you hear where the bass comes from? Below about 80 Hz a sound wave is more than 4 metres long, far bigger than your head. Your ears have nothing to judge the direction by. A subwoofer gives itself away only when it also plays higher frequencies, when it distorts (higher harmonics can be located), or when something in the room rattles.
Below 200 Hz, the room is in charge
Between parallel walls, sound bounces back and forth. When exactly half a wavelength (or a multiple of it) fits between the walls, you get a standing wave, technically a room mode. In some places the waves add up and the note booms; in others they cancel and the note almost disappears. The article The room plays along explains this in detail.
Axial mode between two walls a distance L apart: f = n · c / (2 · L), where c = 343 m/s and n = 1, 2, 3…
A 5 × 4 × 2.5 m room: length 34, 69, 103 Hz; width 43, 86, 129 Hz; height 69, 137 Hz.
The limit above which modes merge into an even reverberant field (the Schroeder frequency): f ≈ 2000 · √(T60 / V). For V = 50 m³ and reverberation T60 = 0.4 s: 2000 · √(0.008) ≈ 180 Hz.
So in a typical living room: below 150 to 200 Hz, what you hear in your seat is decided by the room, not the speaker. Moving the chair or the speaker a few tens of centimetres changes the bass more than swapping the speaker. And an equaliser can't fully fix it: a deep dip at a mode's null is a place where the waves cancel each other. Add power and you boost both waves, which keep cancelling.
Why two beat one
Around 2002, Todd Welti of Harman's research team (where he also worked with Floyd Toole) calculated and measured how the number and position of subwoofers affect the bass in a rectangular room. He didn't look at how a single chair sounds, but at how much the bass differs between several seats. The result, which he later developed further with Allan Devantier in the AES journal, is the basis of today's recommendations:
- One subwoofer gives good bass in one seat, but the seat next to it can sound completely different.
- Two subwoofers at the midpoints of opposite walls, or four (in the corners or at the midpoints of all four walls), greatly reduced the differences between seats.
- More than four added little.
The principle is simple. A mode with opposite phase at the front and rear walls gets two equal but opposite “pushes” from the two subwoofers and never gets going. A subwoofer at the middle of a wall, in turn, sits at the null of the modes that are zero in the middle, so it doesn't excite those either. Fewer excited modes means fewer peaks and dips that change from seat to seat.
The model is simplified (real walls let bass through and absorb it in different ways), but it shows what matters. With one subwoofer, every seat has its own deep dips. With two, the seats are alike and the remaining peaks are the same for everyone. That's where the practical advantage lies: a shared peak can be flattened with EQ for all seats at once. With a single subwoofer, EQ fixes one seat and often makes the others worse.
To be fair, two things should be added. The result depends on the room and on where people sit. If you always sit in the same spot, a single well-placed subwoofer with EQ may be all you need. And in a corner a subwoofer gives more bass for the same signal (about 5 dB in our model), because it excites all the modes at once. So two at the middle of the walls need a bit more power.
Where to put it
Corner: the most bass, the least order
Every nearby wall reflects the bass back, and it adds up with the direct sound. Next to a wall, the deepest bass rises by about 6 dB; in a corner (two walls and the floor), in theory by up to 18 dB compared with free space, less in practice. That's why corners are popular: the subwoofer plays deeper and louder with less power. But every mode has a maximum in the corner, so the subwoofer excites them all as much as possible. A corner is a good starting point, but not always the best result.
The “subwoofer crawl” trick
Acoustics works both ways: if the subwoofer is at A and you sit at B, you hear the same as if it stood at B and you sat at A. That's the basis of a well-known trick, the subwoofer crawl:
- Put the subwoofer on your listening seat, ideally at head height.
- Play music with steady bass, or pink noise limited to 20 to 120 Hz.
- Crawl around the room to the places where the subwoofer could go, with your ear near the floor.
- Where the bass sounds the most even, not the loudest, that's where the subwoofer goes.
The trick is quick and costs nothing. Measuring several positions with a microphone is more accurate; more on that below. You can also work out positions in advance in the room planner, which looks for the spots with the most even bass.
Two subwoofers
If you can, use the midpoints of the front and rear walls, or of the side walls. If the furniture won't allow it, try opposite corners, or one at the front and one at the back. Set both to the same level, then fine-tune them by measuring.
Crossover frequency
The crossover frequency is where the main speakers stop and the subwoofer takes over. The usual range is 60 to 100 Hz.
- 80 Hz is the standard THX introduced for home theatre. It's low enough that the subwoofer can't be located, and high enough to take the load off small speakers too. It usually comes with a steep low-pass for the subwoofer and a gentler high-pass for the main speakers.
- Lower (50 to 60 Hz) makes sense with large speakers that play deep and clean, and with a subwoofer that has to stand far away and off-centre.
- Higher (100 to 120 Hz) only with very small satellites. Here you risk hearing the subwoofer as a separate source, especially if it stands to one side.
Rule of thumb: set the crossover about an octave above the low-frequency limit (F3) of the main speakers, so the filter works where the speakers are still flat. A speaker with F3 = 45 Hz crosses over nicely at 80 to 90 Hz. For a better understanding of how crossovers work, see the article on active and passive crossovers.
Watch out for double filtering: if both the AV receiver and the subwoofer have their own low-pass, the filters stack and leave a hole around the crossover. When connecting through a receiver, set the subwoofer's filter to maximum or “LFE/bypass” and leave the crossover to the receiver.
Phase and delay
Around the crossover frequency, the subwoofer and the main speakers play together. If their waves reach you at the same time and in the same direction, they add up. If they are shifted, they partly cancel and you get a dip at the crossover. Three things cause the shift: distance, filters (every filter adds delay, a steep one more) and, with a digital subwoofer, processing in the DSP.
Example: the subwoofer is 1.5 m farther away than the main speakers.
Delay: 1.5 / 343 ≈ 4.4 ms. One period at 80 Hz lasts 1 / 80 = 12.5 ms.
Phase shift: 4.4 / 12.5 · 360° ≈ 126°. That's already enough for a noticeable dip at the crossover.
A subwoofer deals with this using a phase knob (0 to 180°), a polarity switch or a delay setting in the DSP. An AV receiver asks for distances and works out the delay itself. Remember, though, that filters add their own delay the receiver doesn't know about, so measuring is always more accurate.
A simple test without a computer: play a sine tone at the crossover frequency and turn the phase knob until it is loudest at the listening position. A more precise test with measurement: flip the subwoofer's polarity. In a well-aligned system this creates a deep dip at the crossover. The deeper it is, the better they were aligned before you flipped it. Then switch the polarity back.
Level and measuring with REW
The most common mistake is a subwoofer set too loud. It's fun for the first few days, then the bass starts to tire you and “boom”. The right level is the one where you don't notice the subwoofer until you switch it off.
To measure, all you need is the free program REW (Room EQ Wizard) and a calibrated USB microphone, such as the miniDSP UMIK-1 (roughly €100). The article How to measure a loudspeaker describes how to measure. The procedure for a subwoofer:
- Put the microphone where your head goes, pointing at the ceiling or at the speakers depending on the calibration.
- Measure the left speaker, the right speaker and the subwoofer separately from 15 to 300 Hz.
- Set the subwoofer level so its average level above 30 Hz blends with the main speakers.
- Measure everything together and fine-tune phase or delay until the crossover region is as flat as possible.
- Measure another 5 to 9 spots around your head (within about half a metre) and look at the average. Use EQ only to tame peaks that show up in every spot. Don't fill in dips.
A flat line is not the goal. Research by Sean Olive and colleagues at Harman showed that in a room, most listeners prefer a response that rises gently towards the bass, by a few dB below 100 Hz. Differences between people are large, though, so listen after measuring.
Sealed box or bass reflex
Subwoofers mostly come in two types of enclosure. A sealed box is a solid, airtight box; the air inside acts as a spring. A bass reflex has an opening with a port tube, in which the air oscillates at one frequency like an extra piston and adds bass. A third option is the passive radiator, a bass reflex with a diaphragm instead of a tube.
| Sealed | Bass reflex | |
|---|---|---|
| Roll-off below F3 | 12 dB per octave, gentle | 24 dB per octave, steep |
| Size for the same F3 | smaller, but needs more power and excursion | larger, but more efficient around the tuning |
| Below the tuning frequency | the cone is still damped by the air | the driver “unloads”, a subsonic filter is needed |
| Working with the room | the gentle roll-off pairs well with the gain of a small room | in a small room the deep bass can get overwhelming |
| Equalisation (DSP) | handles a big bass boost if the driver has the excursion | no boosting below the tuning |
| Weak spot | low efficiency | port noise and chuffing with a narrow tube |
The chart shows why this is still debated. A bass reflex gets an octave deeper bass out of the same driver, but in a box two to four times larger. Below 15 Hz, however, it falls off faster than a sealed box. A sealed subwoofer in a small room gets some of the bass back from the room: in an enclosed space the deepest bass gets louder once the waves are longer than the room. That's why small sealed subwoofers often behave better at home than the chart would suggest.
Size versus depth
Bass follows a rule known as Hofmann's Iron Law, after Josef Anton Hofmann, co-founder of KLH. It says that out of three properties you can only pick two: small box, deep bass, high efficiency. A small, deep subwoofer will be inefficient and needs a powerful amplifier and a long-excursion driver. A small, efficient one won't play deep. A deep, efficient one will be big. You can't cheat physics; you only choose what to sacrifice.
Today's small subwoofers take the first route: a small box, a long-excursion driver, a powerful amplifier and DSP that boosts the bass (for example the so-called Linkwitz transform). They play deep, but only up to a certain level. Then they hit the excursion limit.
How much air has to move
Bass loudness depends on how much air the cone moves. At half the frequency, you need four times the volume for the same loudness.
Example: a 30 cm driver, cone area Sd ≈ 0.05 m², excursion ±10 mm. Volume displaced: 0.05 · 0.01 = 0.5 litre.
Sound pressure at 1 m against a wall (half space): p = ρ · ω² · Sd · x / (2π · r).
At 20 Hz: 1.2 · (2π · 20)² · 0.0005 / (2π) ≈ 1.5 Pa peak, so about 1.07 Pa RMS, which is around 95 dB.
At 40 Hz it's 12 dB more, around 107 dB.
Two such subwoofers give 6 dB more at the same excursion, or the same loudness with half the excursion and less distortion.
The room adds something on top, but this shows why small 20 cm drivers can't play 20 Hz loudly, and why two subwoofers pay off in headroom too, not just in evenness.
Stereo or mono bass
With two subwoofers, the obvious question is: should each play its own channel? Most recordings have the lowest bass in the centre, that is, the same in both channels. On vinyl, the lowest bass is often summed to mono during mastering so the stylus doesn't jump out of the groove. Below 80 Hz the ear can hardly tell direction. And the advantage of two subwoofers in evening out modes only works when both play the same signal.
That's why mono is recommended for two subwoofers: both get the sum of the left and right channels. Some researchers and listeners argue that independent bass from the sides adds a sense of space in larger rooms. It's an interesting topic, but in a typical living room the evenness wins. If you have big floorstanders that reach down to 35 Hz, you can let them play the bass in stereo and have the subwoofer just fill in what's missing. Even then, measure to check the waves don't cancel each other.
Home theatre: LFE and bass management
In home theatre, two different things meet that are often confused.
- LFE (Low Frequency Effects, the “.1” in 5.1) is a separate effects channel: explosions, rumble, extra musical bass. It is band-limited to 120 Hz and plays back 10 dB louder than the other channels. That's how films are mixed; it's not a mistake.
- Bass management is a receiver function: from every channel you set to “small”, it filters out the bass below the crossover frequency and sends it to the subwoofer together with the LFE.
In practice: set all speakers to “small” with a crossover around 80 Hz, even large floorstanders. That way the bass comes from where you can even it out, and the speakers don't interfere with each other. If you have two subwoofers, modern receivers have two outputs, often with separate settings for each. The receiver's automatic calibration (Audyssey, Dirac, YPAO and the like) is a good start, but check its result by measuring.
Build your own subwoofer with Loudsmith
A subwoofer is one of the most rewarding things to build. There's no crossover made of components, just one driver and a box. For the price of a mid-range ready-made subwoofer you can build a bigger, deeper one, and often two for the same money.
- In the app, on the Brief tab, choose Speaker type: Subwoofer, or in the Project menu start from the Subwoofer template. You enter how big the box can be and how deep you want the bass. More in the manual.
- Pick a subwoofer driver from the catalogue. The designer calculates suitable boxes for each driver, sealed, bass reflex and passive radiator, and shows their response and maximum loudness.
- A subwoofer has no passive crossover. Crossover and EQ are handled by an active amplifier with DSP. Loudsmith can design an active version with Hypex DSP, and Hypex's FusionAmp range includes a single-channel subwoofer module. A ready-made “plate” amplifier with DSP works too.
- In the Room tool you'll see your room's modes and how your design will meet them.
- After building, measure and set it up following the procedure above.
When building: walls of MDF or plywood at least 18 mm thick, 25 mm or bracing for larger boxes. A subwoofer moves a lot of pressure, and a weak wall starts to vibrate. The bass reflex port must be wide enough, or it will whistle when played loud. Loudsmith warns you about this when designing the port.
What to choose when
| Situation | Recommendation |
|---|---|
| Floorstanders down to 35 to 40 Hz, mostly acoustic music, you listen alone | No subwoofer needed. Work on placement and bass EQ instead. |
| Bookshelf speakers, you want deeper bass or more volume | One subwoofer, 80 Hz crossover, placed with the “subwoofer crawl” or by measuring. |
| Several seats, family, a sofa | Two subwoofers, ideally at the midpoints of opposite walls, mono signal, shared EQ. |
| Home theatre | At least one, two are better; all speakers “small” with an 80 Hz crossover. |
| Small room, small budget | One sealed subwoofer with DSP. Two cheaper ones often beat one expensive one. |
| The bass “booms” at one frequency | First move the subwoofer and measure. Only then use EQ on that one peak. |
If you can't decide between one expensive subwoofer and two cheaper ones, both research and practice point to two. And with a big box and low tuning, you can do even better by building them yourself.
Key takeaways
- Below 200 Hz, the room decides, not the speaker. A note can vary by as much as 20 dB from one spot in the room to another.
- Two subwoofers even out the bass for several seats at once. In our model, the gap between peaks and dips dropped from 41 to 20 dB.
- Placement and measurement before EQ. Peaks can be tamed; dips can't be filled.
- Crossover around 80 Hz, fine-tune phase by measuring. You don't notice a well-set subwoofer until you switch it off.
- Deep, small and efficient all at once is impossible. Pick two out of three.
A subwoofer is the ideal first build: one driver, a simple box, no passive crossover. In Loudsmith you can compare a sealed box, a bass reflex and a passive radiator for the same driver in a few minutes, and see how much bass each one delivers.
Short glossary
- Room mode: a standing wave between walls that boosts the bass in some places and weakens it in others.
- Schroeder frequency: the limit below which individual modes dominate, around 150 to 200 Hz in a living room.
- Crossover frequency: the frequency where the signal is split between the subwoofer and the main speakers.
- F3: the frequency where the bass falls 3 dB below the average.
- Phase: the time shift of a wave expressed in degrees; 360° is one full period.
- Polarity: whether the cone moves out or in on a positive signal.
- LFE: the separate effects channel in home theatre, the “.1” in 5.1.
- Bass management: filtering the bass out of the speakers and redirecting it to the subwoofer.
- Subsonic filter: a filter that cuts off notes below the subwoofer's range so the driver doesn't exceed its excursion.
- Excursion (Xmax): how far the cone can move without heavy distortion.
- REW: Room EQ Wizard, a free program for acoustic measurements.
Sources: T. Welti, Subwoofers: Optimum Number and Locations (AES Convention, 2002); T. Welti and A. Devantier, Low-Frequency Optimization Using Multiple Subwoofers (JAES 2006); F. E. Toole, Sound Reproduction: The Acoustics and Psychoacoustics of Loudspeakers and Rooms (Focal Press, 2008, 3rd ed. Routledge 2017); S. Olive et al., papers on preferred in-room response (AES, 2013 and later); R. H. Small, Closed-Box Loudspeaker Systems (JAES 1972 and 1973); A. N. Thiele, Loudspeakers in Vented Boxes (JAES 1971); M. R. Schroeder, the transition frequency to the diffuse field (1960s); H. Kuttruff, Room Acoustics; REW documentation. The room model and box calculations are our own.
Free tools: Room planner · Speaker measurement · Blind ABX test